Choose a publishing music company by the work you need done. You can administer your own compositions, pay a service to collect specified royalties, use a narrower distributor add-on or negotiate a publisher deal with broader rights.
First, establish who owns and administers each song. Then compare written terms: no company should be assumed to collect every royalty. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Table of content
Introduction
Key Takeaways
What does a publishing company handle?
Which publishing arrangement fits the job?
What should you check before signing?
When is collection different from permission?
How do you organise each song before making a claim?
Example: two writers, one self-released recording
Frequently Asked Questions
Conclusion
Key Takeaways
Choose by task: administer your own songs, appoint an administrator, buy a limited add-on or negotiate a publisher deal.
Separate the song from the recording. A distributor delivering your recording does not necessarily administer the composition.
Compare the written scope first: covered songs, territories, royalty streams, commission bases, rights granted and exit terms matter more than a headline price.
Check existing registrations and claims before submitting new ones, especially when a co-writer or administrator handles part of a song.
What does a publishing company handle?

Music publishing concerns the management and licensing of a composition: the song written by its composers and lyricists. A recording of that song is a separate work, potentially with a different owner. Paying a distributor to deliver your recording does not, by itself, appoint anyone to collect the composition’s royalties. The US Copyright Office’s explanation of the two works is a useful starting point if your credits or agreements mix them up.
A writer may own a composition share and appoint a publisher or administrator to handle specified rights. A performance-rights organisation collects public-performance royalties; for covered US digital audio uses, The MLC collects mechanical royalties. Neither replaces the other. Different shares or works can also have different administrators, so ask who is authorised to claim the particular income you want managed.
For more on what a publisher does, see Musosoup’s guide to music publishing. The decision here is which work to keep, pay someone to administer or grant to a publisher.
Which publishing arrangement fits the job?
A free collection membership, a paid administration service and a negotiated publishing agreement solve different problems. Compare these four routes against the songs and shares you actually control.
Self-administer if you can maintain the records
This suits a writer who controls their share and is willing to handle eligible registrations, matching and statement checks. The MLC offers free membership to eligible self-administered rightsholders for its US digital audio mechanical remit.
Free MLC membership does not settle the costs or requirements of other registrations. For example, US Copyright Office registration is a separate application with a fee; check which registrations are relevant to your songs. Musosoup’s self-publishing guide covers that route in more detail.
Pay an administrator if collection needs help
Consider an administrator when the registrations and royalty streams in its written scope justify the fee and commission. Ask whether it registers works, resolves matches, handles licensing requests or actively pitches songs. Those are different services.
For a price example, Songtrust advertises a $100 one-time songwriter fee and commissions of 15% on performance and 20% on non-performance worldwide mechanical royalties it collects. Its fee explanation distinguishes the writer’s share paid directly by a PRO. These are advertised terms for that service, not standard industry percentages. Musosoup’s publishing-administrator comparison lists more services to investigate.
Use a distributor add-on only for its stated scope
An optional add-on may suit you if you already use the distributor and need a specific collection service it offers. Check the written agreement for eligible releases, composition shares, royalty types and territories; The MLC’s guidance on service agreements explains why distribution should not be assumed to include publishing administration.
Compare the add-on’s charges with the income it actually covers, and ask whether it handles registrations, licensing requests or only specified collections. Do not treat a limited add-on as full worldwide publishing administration or assume that optional representation promises a placement.
Negotiate a publisher deal for a broader relationship
A negotiated deal may make sense if a company offers specific creative, licensing or administrative work you want beyond collection. It is not an open sign-up substitute for an administrator. Ask what it will do for your songs, whether it requires an assignment or exclusive grant, how an advance is recouped and what happens when the term ends.
There is no useful standard percentage to assume in place of the actual offer. If you are pursuing this route, Musosoup’s guide to securing a publishing deal addresses the next stage.
What should you check before signing?
Request written answers for the same song from each company. A lower fee is little help if the service omits the royalty stream you need; a broader offer may grant rights you would rather retain.
Scope: Which songs, composition shares, uses and territories are covered? Who registers them and handles conflicting claims?
Control: Is the agreement exclusive? Are rights assigned or only administered? Can you approve or refuse proposed sync uses?
Money: What fee, commission base, deductions, payment schedule and reporting apply? If there is an advance, which income recoups it?
Exit: How long is the term, what can still be collected afterwards, and how are claims transferred or withdrawn? What statement-query or audit rights do you have?
Check your recording-distribution agreement separately. It may contain an optional publishing service, but ordinary delivery should not be assumed to include one. Musosoup’s distribution-contract checklist helps with that distinct agreement.
When is collection different from permission?
Appointing a company to collect royalties on your composition does not give you permission to use somebody else’s work. If you record a cover, you make a new recording but still use another party’s composition. Check the intended formats, territories and your distributor’s requirements before release; the US Copyright Office’s guidance on using music is a starting point, not a substitute for checking the licence required for your particular use.
For a film, advert or other audiovisual use, check permission for the composition and, if an existing recording is used, the master too. The US Copyright Office’s licensing guide distinguishes these licences and does not describe a compulsory sync or master-use licence. For a sample, interpolation or cross-border use, get advice on the particular rights before agreeing to a placement.
How do you organise each song before making a claim?
Make a song record before paying for administration or filing a new claim. The MLC split-sheet toolkit can help document agreed writer shares. Keep existing publishing agreements and relevant licences with that record rather than relying on memory when a statement arrives.
Confirm ownership. List every writer, their agreed composition shares, any publisher or administrator for each share, and the recording owner. Resolve an unsigned or disputed split before submitting it as agreed.
Gather identifiers and evidence. Record consistent writer and publisher names, the song title, available IPIs and ISWC, and the recording title and ISRC where available. Keep agreements, split sheets, licences and past statements. The MLC’s identifier guide explains these identifiers; not every identifier is required before an MLC registration.
Check existing claims. Verify the relevant performance registrations and ask any appointed administrator what it has registered. For an eligible self-administered US digital audio mechanical share, search for the work in The MLC Member Hub before adding it. If a record exists, check whether your share can be claimed rather than creating a duplicate.
Assign and verify the work. Complete the registrations within your chosen service’s scope or obtain confirmation of what the administrator will do. Check titles, shares and available recording matches, then save confirmations and note who is responsible for each future correction.
Reconcile statements. Compare reported songs, uses, territories, collection periods, deductions and payments with your record. Query a missing or conflicting entry with the organisation responsible for that share before filing another claim.
Example: two writers, one self-released recording
Imagine Asha and Ben agree in writing to own 50% each of a composition, while Asha owns the recording. That split is an illustrative exercise, not a customary arrangement. Ben already has an administrator for his share; Asha is deciding whether to administer hers or pay a service. She first asks Ben which songs and territories his agreement covers rather than assuming his administrator also represents her.
Asha compares self-administration with Songtrust’s advertised $100 one-time songwriter fee and 15% performance and 20% non-performance mechanical commissions on royalties it collects. For this exercise, she can maintain her own records and wants to check her eligible US digital audio mechanical share, rather than pay for the broader collection service described in that offer. She chooses to self-administer this song. That decision is about her stated task, not a claim that the paid service would earn less or that her other songs need the same arrangement.
Asha checks the relevant performance registration separately. She then searches for the song in The MLC Member Hub, verifies what Ben’s administrator has claimed and claims her own eligible share if it is available. Before submitting anything, she compares both writers’ names, the composition title and any linked recording information with their signed record.
A mismatch is a query, not a second registration: If Asha’s later statement uses a different song title or shows her share already claimed, she compares identifiers and saved confirmations, then contacts the responsible organisation or administrator. She does not file a duplicate work to try to force a payment. The MLC’s guidance on conflicting claims explains why the right to collect a particular share must be checked.

Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a publishing company to own my songs?
No. Under US copyright rules, protection for an original work begins when it is fixed; appointing a publisher and registering with the US Copyright Office are separate matters. Check who owns the composition under your actual writing and contractual arrangements before granting anyone authority over it.
Can I join The MLC if I use a publisher or administrator?
Possibly for shares you still administer yourself. Check the agreement song by song and ask the appointed party which shares it claims. The MLC’s songwriter checklist distinguishes fully and partially self-administered situations. Do not register an administered share again merely because you wrote it.
Will a publishing administrator get my song placed in an advert?
Do not assume so. Ask whether the agreement includes active pitching, handling incoming sync requests or neither, and who can approve a proposed use. If a placement is offered, check both the composition permission and, where an existing recording is used, the master-use permission; the US Copyright Office’s licensing guide explains the distinction.
What if two companies claim the same royalty share?
Gather both agreements, the agreed splits and the conflicting work records. Ask each company which song, share, territory, use and period it claims, then follow the collecting organisation’s conflict process. An extra registration does not settle who has the right to collect. Seek a qualified music lawyer if ownership or contractual authority remains disputed.
When should I have a music lawyer review the agreement?
Get qualified advice before signing an assignment or exclusive deal you do not understand, particularly if it includes an advance, recoupment or a long post-term collection period. Also seek help with disputed splits, samples or interpolations, cross-border licences, or a material royalty conflict that the parties cannot resolve. A checklist can identify questions; it cannot determine your legal position.
Conclusion
Start with one song: confirm its writers, shares, existing claims and recording owner. Then request comparable written terms from any companies on your shortlist. Decide who will administer each composition share before adding or changing a registration.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Stay updated with the latest Muso news, tips, and success stories. Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss an update!




